Skip to content
Pickerify

Which comment picker should you use for your giveaway?

The right comment picker depends on how big your giveaway is, whether you want to log in, and how much proof your audience expects. Here’s an honest comparison with popular tools, checked on each tool’s own website on 28 October 2026.

Three kinds of tools, three different jobs

The tools on this page don't all do the same job. Knowing which kind you need narrows the choice quickly.

  • Comment pickers load the comments on a post and draw a random winner: Pickerify, CommentPicker, Iconosquare, Gleam, Free Comment Picker, CommentShark and Pickfetti. They differ mainly in whether you log in, how many comments are free and how the draw can be checked.
  • Promotion platforms run a whole campaign, from entry forms and hosted terms to winner pages: Easypromos. They suit brands with regular campaigns and a monthly budget.
  • Comment exporters download comments into a spreadsheet without picking anyone: CommentGrid, and the export tools from Pickerify, CommentPicker and Pickfetti.

How do the comment pickers compare?

Checked on each tool's own website on 28 October 2026. Prices in US dollars.

ItemLogin neededFree limitPaid optionsPlatformsRules and filtersProof of fairness
PickerifyNone1,000 comments per post, unlimited draws; 10 winners and 5 backupsPasses $4.99–$14.99 once (up to 200,000 comments); Pro $12/monthInstagram, Facebook, YouTube, TikTok, pasted listsTags, keyword, one entry per person, exclusions, entry window, repliesPublic results page with seed and entry hash
CommentPickerInstagram or Facebook login; Business or Creator accountOne winner from one post with up to 100 commentsPremium $9.99/month or $95.91/year (via Patreon), up to 10 winnersInstagram and other social platformsExclusions and entries per user; more on PremiumPseudorandom generator; no published seed
EasypromosInstagram account via Meta's official API; business accountsFirst giveaway on an organic (not promoted) postPlans from $29/month (Basic, up to 5,000 comments)Instagram, Facebook, X, Instagram + Facebook togetherHashtags, dates, blacklist, previous winnersCertificate of validity and a winners page
IconosquareInstagram login; business account linked to a Facebook PageFree, no comment limitNoneInstagram posts, carousels and ReelsNot statedDownloadable certificate; suggests recording your screen
GleamInstagram login; Business or Creator account linked to a Facebook PageFewer than 200 commentsFrom $3.99 per post (up to 1,000 comments); larger posts priced per commentInstagramNot statedWinner results page
Free Comment PickerNoneOne draw a day; comment limit not statedPro $7.99/month: no daily limit, more comments per drawInstagram, TikTok, YouTube, FacebookKeyword, one entry per person, @mentions (not on Facebook), exclude previous winnersScreen recording of the draw
CommentSharkNone for the free versionFirst 500 commentsSigning in unlocks higher limits; picker price not statedYouTube videos and ShortsUnique authors, replies, text, before/after dateNot stated
PickfettiNone500 comments per post; 5 winners and 3 alternatesPasses $4.99–$14.99 once (up to 100,000 comments); Pro $9/month or $79/yearInstagram, YouTubeTags, keyword, one entry per person, follow check, exclusions, date window, repliesPublic proof page with seed and entry hash

Comment export

ItemPlatformsFormatsFree limitLogin needed
PickerifyInstagramCSV, Excel, JSONPosts up to 1,000 commentsNone
CommentPickerInstagram, plus separate Facebook, YouTube and TikTok exportersCSV, XLSX50 comments, 1 export a day, 3 a monthInstagram login; Business or Creator account
CommentGridTikTok, YouTube, Instagram, Facebook (Chrome extension)Excel, CSV, JSON300 credits, up to 100 comments per exportNot stated
Pickfetti (IGComments)InstagramCSV, Excel, JSONUp to 200 commentsNone

“Not stated” means we couldn’t find it on the tool’s own site, not that the feature is missing. Spotted something out of date? Email hello@pickerify.com and we’ll correct it.

Which tool fits your giveaway

No single tool is best for every giveaway. Pick the one that matches your size, your platforms and how much you want to connect.

  • Choose Pickerify if you want to draw from Instagram, Facebook, YouTube or TikTok without logging in, your post has up to 1,000 comments, or you want entrants to verify the result themselves.
  • Choose Iconosquare if you have a business Instagram account, need a big post drawn for free, and don’t need entrants to verify the draw.
  • Choose CommentPicker if you’re comfortable logging in and want many small free social tools in one place.
  • Choose Gleam if you already run competitions on Gleam and your post has fewer than 200 comments.
  • Choose Easypromos if you’re a brand or agency that needs the official API, Story or promoted-post giveaways and hosted terms, and a monthly plan fits your budget.
  • Choose Free Comment Picker if one draw a day is enough and a screen recording is enough proof for your audience.
  • Choose CommentShark if you only run YouTube giveaways under 500 comments.
  • Choose CommentGrid if you only need comments in a spreadsheet and don’t need to pick a winner.
  • Choose Pickfetti if you only need Instagram or YouTube, your giveaways stay under 500 comments and a $9 Pro plan saves you money.

For free options only, see the best free Instagram comment pickers in 2026.

When Pickerify isn't the right choice

Pickerify is built for fair, verifiable draws from public posts. For some giveaways, another tool on this page fits better.

  • You need Story or promoted-post giveaways. Easypromos supports Instagram Story giveaways and posts promoted with ads, which a public-comment picker can’t read.
  • You want everything inside one campaign platform. For entry forms, hosted terms and a branded winners page in one place, a promotion platform fits better.
  • The post is on a private account. No link-based picker can read it. Copy the entries into a list, or use a tool that connects to your own account.
  • Your post has more than 200,000 comments. That’s above Pickerify’s largest pass. Email us for a quote.

How we compared

We compared the tools on the questions hosts ask most, using only what each tool says on its own website.

  • Criteria: login, free limit, paid options, platforms, rules and filters, proof of fairness and comment export.
  • Sources: each tool’s own pricing, help and FAQ pages, checked on 28 October 2026. Gleam’s pages were read through search results, because its site blocks automated reading.
  • Our bias: Pickerify is our product. We’ve tried to give every tool’s real strengths, and we update this page every month or as soon as a correction comes in.

See how Pickerify’s own draw works, in full detail: how it works.

Comparison questions

Which comment picker has the highest free limit?

It depends on the platform and the login. Iconosquare says its Instagram picker has no comment limit but needs a business account login. Among no-login pickers, Pickerify allows 1,000 comments per post, Pickfetti 500 and CommentShark the first 500 YouTube comments. Gleam is free under 200 comments and CommentPicker up to 100.

Which comment pickers don't need a login?

Pickerify, Pickfetti and Free Comment Picker read public comments without any login, and CommentShark's free YouTube picker needs no sign-up. CommentPicker, Iconosquare, Gleam and Easypromos connect to your Instagram account and need a business or creator account.

Which tools work with TikTok?

Pickerify and Free Comment Picker pick winners from TikTok comments from a link, and CommentGrid and CommentPicker can export TikTok comments.

Is Easypromos worth it for a single giveaway?

Your first giveaway on an organic post is free on Easypromos. After that it's a monthly plan from $29, which suits brands running several campaigns more than a one-off giveaway.

Which tool is the most transparent?

Tools that publish the random seed and a fingerprint of the entry list let anyone rerun the draw. Of the tools compared here, Pickerify and Pickfetti do this; the others rely on a certificate, a results page or a screen recording.

Try Pickerify on your next giveaway

Paste a post link and see the price before anything runs. For posts with up to 1,000 comments, it's free.

Pick a winner
Want the details first? See what’s free and all plans.