- Free up to 1,000 comments
- No Google login
- Videos and Shorts
Free YouTube Comment Picker for Giveaways
Paste the link to a YouTube video or Short. Pickerify reads the public comments and replies, filters them by the rules in your description and picks a random winner in seconds, with a results page your viewers can check.
- Free up to 1,000 comments per draw
- No social media login
- Winner in seconds
Giveaway in your live chat or Discord? Paste the names into the random comment picker.
| Free limit | Any public video or Short with up to 1,000 comments, unlimited draws |
|---|---|
| Login | None. No Google account, channel access or permissions |
| Video types | Regular videos, Shorts and finished premieres or live streams |
| Replies | Read too, so a keyword in a reply still counts |
| Rules | Keyword or hashtag, one entry per person, @mention minimum, excluded channels, entry window |
| Winners | Up to 10 winners and 5 backups free, up to 100 on Pro |
| Proof | Results page with the seed and entry hash, a winner image and the entry list |
| Bigger videos | One-time passes from $4.99 |
How to pick a winner from YouTube comments
Choosing a YouTube giveaway winner takes four steps, and they're the same for a regular video and a Short.
- 1
Copy the video link
On a regular video, tap Share under the player and choose Copy link. On a Short, tap the share arrow on the right and choose Copy link. On a computer, you can also copy the address from your browser bar.
- 2
Paste it and check the video
Pickerify shows the channel, the video title and the price before any comments are loaded.
- 3
Add the rules from your description
Set what you asked viewers to do, such as commenting a keyword or answering a question, and choose how many winners and backups you need.
- 4
Draw and announce
Pickerify picks from the qualifying comments in seconds. Pin a comment with the winner's name and the results page link, or show the result in your next video.
Step by step with screenshots: how to pick a winner from YouTube comments
Turn your video description into rules
YouTube giveaways usually ask viewers to comment, and sometimes to subscribe or like. Pickerify checks the comment part; subscribing and liking can't be verified by any picker.
| Your description says | Pickerify setting | Can it be checked? |
|---|---|---|
| “Comment your favourite moment” | No rule needed; every comment is an entry | Yes |
| “Comment GIVEAWAY to enter” | Required keyword | Yes, in any letter case |
| “One comment per person” | One entry per person | Yes, by channel |
| “Mention a friend's channel” | Tag-a-friend minimum: 1 | Yes, by @handles in comments and replies |
| “Ends Sunday at 23:59” | Entry window | Yes |
| “Subscribe to enter” | — | No. YouTube keeps subscription lists private by default |
| “Like the video” | — | No. YouTube doesn't show who liked a video |
If you mention subscribing or liking, present them as optional and check the winner by hand. YouTube’s contest policies, covered below, also forbid manipulating views, likes or subscriber counts.
Which YouTube comments the picker can read
Pickerify reads the comments anyone can see under a public or unlisted video. What YouTube hides from the public, it can't read either.
| Where the entries are | Works? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Comments on a public video | Yes | Visible to everyone |
| Comments on a Short | Yes | Shorts comments work like video comments |
| Comments on an unlisted video | Yes | Anyone with the link can see them |
| Comments after a premiere or live stream ends | Yes | They stay under the video like any comment |
| Live chat during a stream | No | Chat messages aren't stored as comments; paste the names into the random comment picker |
| Private or members-only videos | No | Only invited viewers or members can see them |
| Videos made for kids | No | YouTube turns comments off on these videos |
Why some comments aren’t read: comments held for review, removed by the channel or hidden as likely spam aren’t public, so no tool can read them. Approve genuine held comments in YouTube Studio before drawing. Each draw reads comments for a set time; paid plans read longer.
Free for most YouTube giveaways
Videos and Shorts with up to 1,000 comments are free to draw from. For bigger videos you pay once for that draw, and you see the price before any comments are loaded.
| Comments on the video | Price |
|---|---|
| Up to 1,000 | Free |
| Up to 15,000 | $4.99 once |
| Up to 50,000 | $9.99 once |
| Up to 200,000 | $14.99 once |
| Giveaways every month | Pro, $12/month |
Each draw reads comments for a set time; paid plans read longer. All plans and limits
What YouTube requires from your giveaway
YouTube makes the creator solely responsible for a contest and sets a few rules every giveaway on the platform has to follow.
According to YouTube’s contest policies, your giveaway must:
- be free to enter
- have official rules that link to YouTube’s Community Guidelines and say that YouTube isn’t a sponsor
- include a privacy notice explaining how you’ll use entrants’ data
- not manipulate views, likes or subscriber counts
- not run through ad units
Pickerify picks the winner fairly, but it doesn’t run, sponsor or judge your giveaway. The giveaway rules generator drafts official rules that cover these points.
YouTube comment picker questions
Is the YouTube comment picker free?
Yes, any public video or Short with up to 1,000 comments is free to draw from, with every rule, up to 10 winners and 5 backups, and a results page. Bigger videos start at $4.99 per draw.
Do I need to sign in with Google?
No. Pickerify reads the public comments from the video link and never asks for your Google account, channel access or permissions. It can't comment, reply or change anything on your channel.
Can I make sure the winner is subscribed?
No picker can. YouTube keeps subscription lists private by default, so there's no reliable way to check. Keep “subscribe” as an optional suggestion rather than an entry rule.
Does it work with YouTube Shorts?
Yes. Copy the Short's link from the share menu and paste it like any other video.
Can I pick from a live stream?
Yes for comments left under the video after the stream, no for messages in the live chat. Chat messages aren't stored as comments, so paste chat names into a list instead.
How can viewers check the draw was fair?
Every draw gets a results page with the rules, the random seed and a fingerprint of the entry list. Its verification file reruns the draw and confirms the same winners.
Pick your YouTube winner
Paste the video or Shorts link, add the rules from your description and share a result your viewers can verify.
Pick my YouTube winner