Skip to content
Pickerify

How to Pick a Winner From YouTube Comments (Step by Step)

By the Pickerify team · Last updated 28 October 2026 · 7 min read

To pick a winner from YouTube comments, approve any comments held for review, copy the video or Short’s link, paste it into a comment picker, set the rules from your description and draw winners and backups together. Then pin a comment with the result so every viewer can see it.

Before you draw

Approve held comments. YouTube holds some comments for review, especially ones with links or certain words. They stay invisible to everyone else, including any comment picker, until you approve them in YouTube Studio.

Where people enteredCan a picker read it?
Comments on a public or unlisted videoYes
Comments on a ShortYes
Comments under a premiere or a finished live streamYes
Messages in the live chat during a streamNo; paste the names into the random comment picker
Comments on a private or members-only videoNo

Write down your rules. Closing time and time zone, what a valid comment must contain, whether each person gets one entry, and how many winners and backups you need. YouTube’s contest policies also ask for free entry and official rules that say YouTube isn’t a sponsor; the giveaway rules generator covers those points.

Step by step

  1. Close the giveaway. At your deadline, add “Giveaway closed” to the top of the description or pin a comment saying so. The entry window makes sure late comments don't count.
  2. Copy the video link. Under a regular video, tap Share and choose Copy link. On a Short, tap the share arrow and choose Copy link.
  3. Paste it into the picker. In the YouTube comment picker, paste the link and check the channel and the title before reading the comments.
  4. Set the rules. Add the entry window, a required keyword if your description asked for one, one entry per person, and exclude your own channel.
  5. Draw winners and backups. Choose how many of each and draw them together.
  6. Share the result. Copy the results page link for your announcement so viewers can check the draw.

Rules: what you can check on YouTube

Can be checked from the comments

  • Commenting, including replies under other comments.
  • A keyword or answer, such as “comment GIVEAWAY” or your favourite moment.
  • One entry per channel, so repeat comments don’t add extra chances.
  • Mentions, if you asked people to mention a friend’s @handle.

Can’t be checked

  • Subscribing. YouTube keeps subscription lists private by default.
  • Liking the video. YouTube doesn’t show who liked a video.

YouTube’s contest policies also forbid manipulating views, likes or subscriber counts, so keep “subscribe” and “like” as friendly suggestions.

Announcing and contacting the winner

YouTube has no direct messages, so the winner has to come to you. Make that easy and safe.

  1. Pin a comment with the result. Name the winner, link the results page and say how to claim the prize, for example by emailing an address shown in your channel’s About section, within 72 hours.
  2. Reply to the winning comment. The winner gets a notification, and everyone can see the reply came from your channel.
  3. Mention it in your next video or Community post for viewers who missed the pinned comment.
  4. No reply by the deadline? Update the pinned comment: the prize goes to backup 1, linking the same results page.

A pinned comment you can adapt

🎉 Giveaway closed! Congratulations @winner, picked at random. Check the draw: [results page link]. Please email [your email] within 72 hours to claim your prize. We’ll never ask for a payment or your password.

Watch out for impersonators. Scam accounts often copy a creator’s name and picture, reply to comments saying “you’ve won” and send people to a link or chat app. Say in your pinned comment exactly how winners will be contacted. To check a draw, see how verification works.

FAQ

Can I pick a winner from YouTube Shorts comments?

Yes. Copy the Short's link from the share menu and use it like any other video link.

Can I require viewers to subscribe?

You can ask, but no tool can check it, because subscription lists are private by default. YouTube's contest policies also forbid manipulating subscriber counts, so make subscribing optional.

Why are some comments missing from the draw?

Comments held for review, removed by you or hidden as likely spam aren't public. Approve genuine held comments in YouTube Studio before drawing.

Can I pick from my live stream?

Comments left under the video after the stream are fine. Live chat messages aren't stored as comments, so paste chat names into a list instead.

How do I contact the winner on YouTube?

Pin a comment and reply to the winner's comment asking them to email you. YouTube has no direct messages, so never send winners to an outside chat app.

Ready to pick your YouTube winner?

Paste the link to your video or Short, set the rules from your description and get a winner with a results page viewers can check. Free for videos with up to 1,000 comments.

Pick my YouTube winner